C-FITAQP: 9) NON-STABILIZED APPCH.

Learjet 35A | N81VN

Scottsdale, Arizona

  • DTSB analysis published
Share a tip about this accident

Key facts

  • DateFebruary 10, 2025
  • Local time2:40 PM
  • LightDay
  • WeatherVMC
  • Phase of flightLanding
  • People on board4
  • Fatalities1
  • AirportKSDL

Accident Location

City, State
Scottsdale, Arizona
Latitude
33.621944
Longitude
-111.909722
Airport ID
KSDL

Aircraft Info

N Number
N81VN
Make
Learjet
Model
35A
Category / Class
Aircraft Multi Engine Land
Amateur Built
No

Pilot Info

Pilot in command
Joie Davis Vitosky
Gender
Male
Age
78
Certification
Airline Transport Pilot
IFR rating
Yes
Medical
2nd Class Medical
Flight school
No
Instructional flight
No

Analysis

Weather
VMC
Time of day
Day
Phase of flight
Landing
Pilot error
Yes
Pilot incapacitation
No
People on board
4
PIC fatality
1
Total fatalities
1
NTSB travel
Unknown

Probable Cause

THE DTSB

The DTSB determines the Probable Cause of this accident to be Pilot Error, in that the pilot flew a non stabilized visual approach to runway 21, varying both speed and rate of descent on final. This set up the PIO for a very hard landing which followed. According to eye witness accounts, the aircraft first impacted in a nose high very hard landing, whereupon it bounced back up into the air. When it touched down the second time the left main landing gear gave way at the upper attach point, causing the left wing to fall down, and pull the aircraft to the left. The aircraft was not equipped with thrust reversers and max braking from the remaining right wheel brake system was not sufficient to stop the aircraft before it collided with another parked aircraft. Early reports indicate that this same aircraft had recently experienced a hard landing and damage to the same component. A photo of the aircraft shows that the left main landing gear is out of place as compared to the right, which likely completely failed during the hard landing. The left seat pilot was killed on impact, the right seat pilot was pinned in the wreckage and was unable to stop the engine from running after the impact.

NTSB

None yet (final report not yet published).

Recommendation

THE DTSB

The DTSB recommends that all pilots of all aircraft rehearse and condition themselves to be able to fly a precise visual stabilized approach to the white boxes and be ready and able to perform a safe go around very early when the approach is not fully stabilized below 500 AGL. This pilot was not killed by the crash. He was killed by the non stabilized approach which was the start of the fatal sequence.

Resources